Bryan King, a former Aston Villa scout, believes Aston Villa are in a stronger position than Tottenham Hotspur to secure the signing of Malik Tillman from PSV Eindhoven. King argues that Unai Emery’s side could present the American midfielder with the guarantees he would need to consider a move to the West Midlands.
As reported by TBR Football on 23 November, both Aston Villa and Tottenham have expressed interest in acquiring Tillman, who has been impressive since making his move to PSV Eindhoven permanent this summer. Initially joining the Dutch side on loan from Bayern Munich, Tillman’s performances have drawn widespread attention. Bayern, however, included a £30 million buy-back clause in the deal, meaning PSV could be incentivized to entertain offers of that value from interested clubs.
King, speaking to Villa News, explained why he believes Aston Villa hold an edge over their Premier League rivals. He emphasized the importance of playing time, particularly for a player of Tillman’s caliber.
“There is one thing you’ve got to do as a club when you’re buying a player of that calibre, you’ve got to give the player minutes,” King remarked.
Why Aston Villa Could Win the Race for Tillman
Tillman, 22, has proven himself to be a highly talented and versatile midfielder. His ability to contribute both goals and assists makes him an attractive prospect for any top club. Last season, he was instrumental in PSV Eindhoven’s title-winning campaign, registering nine goals and ten assists. This season, he has already scored five goals in just 13 Eredivisie appearances, further underscoring his potential and consistency.
The interest from clubs like Aston Villa and Tottenham comes as no surprise, but King sees Villa as the more appealing option for Tillman. While Tottenham boast significant resources and ambition under manager Ange Postecoglou, their squad depth, particularly in midfield, could limit the 22-year-old’s opportunities for first-team football. In contrast, Aston Villa could provide him with a clearer path to regular playing time.
Moreover, Aston Villa’s potential to offer UEFA Champions League football might also be a decisive factor. The Villans have been performing well under Emery, and their strong form in the Premier League and European competitions makes them an increasingly attractive destination for rising stars like Tillman. On the other hand, Tottenham are currently unable to offer Champions League football, which could play into Villa’s hands when negotiating a deal.
The Importance of Unai Emery’s Role
However, Aston Villa’s ability to secure Tillman’s signature may also hinge on keeping hold of Unai Emery. The Spanish manager has transformed the club’s fortunes since his arrival, turning them into genuine contenders in both domestic and European competitions. Speculation over Emery’s future, fueled by recent rumors of potential exit plans, could complicate Villa’s recruitment efforts. Tillman and his representatives will undoubtedly want clarity on the managerial situation before committing to any move.
What’s Next for Aston Villa and Malik Tillman?
Aston Villa’s pursuit of Tillman highlights their ambition to strengthen their squad with young, dynamic talent. The 22-year-old midfielder has all the qualities to thrive in the Premier League, but whether Villa can beat Tottenham to his signature remains to be seen. Both clubs are likely to face stiff competition, not only from each other but potentially from Bayern Munich as well, should the German giants decide to activate their buy-back clause.
In other news, Aston Villa are reportedly interested in signing a Manchester United player, with updates on potential departures also emerging. The January transfer window promises to be a busy and critical period for the club as they look to build on their impressive recent progress.
