Newcastle 0 West Ham 2: A Night to Forget at St. James’ Park
Monday night’s clash at St. James’ Park ended with Newcastle United succumbing to a disappointing 0-2 defeat against West Ham United. It was a game that showcased both the struggles and missed opportunities of Eddie Howe’s men. As is customary, we analyze the match by exploring three positives and three negatives.
Plenty to dissect here after a frustrating outing under the floodlights…
Positives (though few and far between):
1. The Return of Callum Wilson
Among the scarce bright spots was the return of Callum Wilson. After an injury-laden career, seeing him back on the pitch offered a glimmer of hope. His presence reminded fans of his natural goal-scoring ability, even if he couldn’t quite make the difference on the night. Fitness remains a concern, but if Wilson can stay fit and rediscover his sharpness, he might yet lead the line effectively in the weeks to come. On a tough night, these were valuable minutes for the forward.
2. Small Margins, Different Result
Football can be a game of fine margins, and Monday’s loss served as a case study in “what could have been.” Newcastle created chances and arguably should have had a penalty, which could have changed the complexion of the game entirely. The performance may not have been stellar, but on another day, with a bit more luck or decisiveness in front of goal, a draw—or even a victory—might have been achievable. This slim silver lining may offer some solace to fans.
3. The Bigger Picture
Despite the defeat, there’s still room for optimism when considering the broader context of the season. It’s early days in the Premier League campaign, and Newcastle sit just a point away from sixth place. Eddie Howe and his players have navigated tough patches before and proven their ability to bounce back. The league remains unforgiving, but Newcastle’s squad—albeit a few players short—has shown resilience in prior seasons. There’s time to regroup and refocus.
—
Negatives (where do we begin?):
1. Tactical and Individual Failures
Monday night exposed a plethora of issues, both tactically and individually. Key players underperformed—Isak and Gordon were subdued, Joelinton seemed miscast on the right flank, and Barnes failed to influence proceedings. The decision to switch to a 4-4-2 formation backfired, leaving Newcastle unable to break down a defensively solid West Ham side. Defensively, the pairing of Kelly and Schar was less than convincing, with Schar in particular far from his best. These shortcomings highlight gaps that Eddie Howe must address quickly.
2. Mental Fragility in the Second Half
What happened after halftime? Newcastle fell apart in the second half, unable to respond after conceding two goals. Panic set in, and composure was nowhere to be found. This isn’t the first time Newcastle has struggled against teams they’re expected to beat, with similar collapses against Brighton, Everton, Fulham, and Bournemouth earlier in the season. West Ham, a team in turmoil with manager Julen Lopetegui reportedly under pressure, were gifted an undeserved lifeline. Newcastle’s inability to seize control in such games raises serious questions about their mentality.
3. Post-Match Head-Scratching
Eddie Howe’s post-match comments sparked confusion among fans. While he praised the team’s overall play in the first 60 minutes, Newcastle trailed by two goals during that period. For the first time in a long while, some supporters found themselves questioning Howe’s perspective. Faith in his leadership remains strong, but his assessment of this match left many unconvinced. Add to this the frustration of yet another late Monday night kickoff—a schedule quirk that some argue disrupted the team’s rhythm—and you have a recipe for disgruntlement.
—
Lingering Questions and Moving Forward
As the dust settles, Newcastle finds itself at a crossroads. How can Eddie Howe address the team’s apparent fragility against mid-to-lower-table sides? Why does the team consistently falter in games they should dominate? These are questions that must be answered if Newcastle is to solidify their place among the Premier League’s elite.
Additionally, the timing of the recent international break seems to have disrupted momentum. Newcastle had been building steam but lost that edge during the two-week pause. Finding consistency in a grueling schedule will be paramount moving forward.
—
Upcoming Fixtures: A Chance to Rebound
The road ahead offers opportunities for redemption, but the challenges are significant. Here’s a glance at Newcastle’s confirmed fixtures through January 2025:
Crystal Palace (A): Saturday 30 November, 3pm
Liverpool (H): Wednesday 4 December, 7:30pm
Brentford (A): Saturday 7 December, 3pm
Leicester (H): Saturday 14 December, 3pm
Brentford (H, Carabao Cup): Wednesday 18 December, 7:45pm
Ipswich (A): Saturday 21 December, 3pm
Aston Villa (H): Thursday 26 December, 3pm
Man United (A): Monday 30 December, 8pm
This stretch includes clashes with Liverpool and Manchester United, as well as winnable matches against Crystal Palace and Ipswich. If Newcastle can navigate this period successfully, they’ll be well-positioned to push for a top-six finish.
—
Final Thoughts
Monday night’s defeat was a bitter pill to swallow for Newcastle United and their supporters. While there are undeniable issues to address, the season remains salvageable. Eddie Howe has proven his managerial mettle before, and fans will be hoping he can galvanize his squad once more. The Premier League waits for no one, and Newcastle must learn from this setback quickly if they are to achieve their ambitions.
