‘He’s Really, Really Good’ – Pep Guardiola Says Man City Have a Hidden Gem Who Reminds Him of Phil Foden… and He Might Just Be the Next Big Star at the Etihad
Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola has addressed the growing speculation surrounding the future of talented midfielder James McAtee, ahead of City’s upcoming Premier League clash with Everton. The 22-year-old, a product of City’s esteemed academy, has endured a stop-start campaign, but recent performances have reminded fans and pundits alike of his immense potential.
McAtee, who previously impressed during loan spells — most notably at Sheffield United — has found it difficult to secure regular game time this season in a squad stacked with world-class talent. However, in recent weeks, he has begun to make his mark. The midfielder made a statement in his first Premier League start last weekend, netting a goal in City’s emphatic 5-2 victory over Crystal Palace, showcasing his attacking instinct and ability to impact the game in the final third.
Despite that strong showing, uncertainty still looms over McAtee’s long-term future at the Etihad. With his contract set to expire in 2026, and interest from several clubs across England and Europe growing, questions have been raised about whether the youngster will remain with the Premier League champions or look elsewhere for more consistent opportunities.
Speaking to the club’s official media team, Guardiola made it clear that he wants McAtee to stay, but also acknowledged the complex reality young players face when trying to break into an elite-level squad.
“For his age, I would love for him to stay,” Guardiola said. “He’s come through the academy, he understands our patterns, he’s versatile, and above all, he’s a fantastic person with a great attitude in training.”
However, Guardiola also conceded that game time is a crucial factor, especially for young players like McAtee, who are hungry to develop and prove themselves on a bigger stage.
“I understand the frustration. All players want to play more, especially someone like Macca, who trains brilliantly and has shown he can deliver when given the chance. But with the size and quality of our squad, it’s always a balancing act. We’ll have to see how the season finishes before making any decisions.”
The City boss was full of praise for McAtee’s attacking instincts, particularly highlighting the similarities between him and Phil Foden, another academy graduate who has become a crucial player for both club and country.
“Macca has that quality inside the box — he reads the game so well and gets into dangerous positions,” Guardiola explained. “Honestly, he could’ve scored three or four goals against Palace. He lives close to the goal, just like Phil. That awareness, that timing, it’s hard to teach. It’s natural, and he’s got it.”
While McAtee’s future at Manchester City is still undecided, what’s certain is that Guardiola sees a bright future for the young midfielder — whether it continues at the Etihad or elsewhere. His recent performances have certainly bolstered his stock, and with more minutes likely before the season ends, he’ll have every opportunity to convince both his manager and the fans that he belongs among City’s stars.
As the summer approaches and clubs continue to monitor his situation, Guardiola’s admiration may be a key factor in persuading McAtee to remain part of City’s long-term plans. But ultimately, the decision could come down to one thing: the promise of regular football.
