In the high-stakes world of Premier League football, where every match is a battle of tactics, skill, and physical prowess, strength is often equated with the ability to overpower opponents. Erling Haaland, with his imposing 6’4″ frame and remarkable goal-scoring abilities, epitomizes this traditional notion of strength. However, Brentford’s manager, Thomas Frank, has offered a compelling counterpoint by declaring that Manchester City’s strongest player isn’t Haaland but midfielder Rodri. This assertion prompts a deeper examination of what constitutes strength in football and how Rodri’s influence on the pitch transcends mere physicality.
Before delving into Frank’s perspective, it’s essential to define what strength means in the context of football. While physical attributes like size and power are evident, strength also encompasses mental resilience, tactical intelligence, and the ability to influence the game’s tempo. Players who can dictate play, recover possession, and maintain composure under pressure demonstrate a different, yet equally vital, form of strength.
Erling Haaland: The Physical Powerhouse
Since joining Manchester City in 2022, Erling Haaland has been a revelation. His goal-scoring record speaks volumes: 120 goals in 138 appearances, averaging nearly a goal per game. Standing at 6’4″ and possessing remarkable speed and agility, Haaland’s physical presence on the field is undeniable. His ability to shield the ball, win aerial duels, and break defensive lines with sheer power makes him a formidable striker.
However, despite his physical dominance, Haaland has expressed dissatisfaction with his performances this season. With 30 goals to his name, his tally remains impressive, yet he feels there’s more to his game that can be refined. This introspection highlights that even the most physically gifted players seek continuous improvement and adaptation.
Rodri: The Unsung Strength
Rodri’s role at Manchester City often goes underappreciated. As a holding midfielder, his primary responsibilities include breaking up opposition attacks, maintaining possession, and distributing the ball efficiently. Yet, his impact on the game is profound. Rodri’s tactical awareness, composure under pressure, and ability to read the game make him the linchpin of City’s midfield.
His physical attributes further enhance his effectiveness. Standing tall and possessing a robust build, Rodri excels in aerial duels and tackles. His 73% tackle success rate and 100% aerial duel success rate during the 2022–23 season underscore his physical prowess. More than just a defensive midfielder, Rodri’s passing accuracy and vision allow him to transition play seamlessly, making him a dual threat both defensively and offensively.
Thomas Frank’s Perspective
Thomas Frank’s assertion that Rodri is Manchester City’s strongest player is rooted in a nuanced understanding of strength. Frank, known for his emphasis on tactical discipline and team cohesion, recognizes that Rodri’s influence extends beyond physical confrontations. In a discussion about building the “perfect player,” Frank highlighted Rodri’s strength, placing him alongside legends like Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, and Andrés Iniesta.
Frank’s perspective challenges the conventional view that strength is solely about physical dominance. Instead, he emphasizes the importance of mental fortitude, tactical intelligence, and the ability to control the game’s rhythm—qualities that Rodri embodies.
Rodri’s Absence and Manchester City’s Struggles
Rodri’s importance to Manchester City became glaringly evident during his absence due to a serious knee injury sustained in September 2024. The team’s performance without him suffered significantly. In the 45 matches without Rodri, City won only 64%, drew 11%, and lost 24%. In contrast, with Rodri in the lineup, the win rate soared to 74%, with a mere 11% loss rate.
Pep Guardiola acknowledged the challenge of replacing Rodri’s unique skill set. While players like Mateo Kovačić and Ilkay Gündoğan attempted to fill the void, none could replicate Rodri’s comprehensive influence on the game. Guardiola’s admission that “this season is over for him” highlighted the magnitude of the loss and the team’s subsequent struggles.
The Tactical Void Left by Rodri
Rodri’s absence forced Manchester City to adapt tactically. Without a natural holding midfielder, Guardiola experimented with various formations and personnel. The reliance on multiple players to cover Rodri’s responsibilities led to a lack of cohesion and balance in the midfield. The team’s defensive solidity weakened, and the fluidity in their attacking transitions diminished.
This tactical void underscored Rodri’s irreplaceable role in City’s system. His ability to shield the defense, recycle possession, and initiate attacks from deep positions is central to Guardiola’s philosophy. Without him, the team’s identity was compromised.
The Road to Recovery
As of May 2025, Rodri has resumed training after a seven-month rehabilitation period. While his return to full fitness is ongoing, the prospect of his comeback offers hope for Manchester City. Guardiola remains cautious, emphasizing the need for medical clearance before reintroducing Rodri to competitive action.
The upcoming Club World Cup presents an opportunity for Rodri to reintegrate into the team. His presence could provide the midfield stability and control that City has sorely missed, potentially influencing their performances in the latter stages of the season.
Conclusion
Thomas Frank’s assertion that Rodri is Manchester City’s strongest player invites a reevaluation of what strength means in football. While physical dominance is valuable, the ability to influence the game’s tempo, maintain composure under pressure, and execute tactical responsibilities with precision constitutes a different, yet equally vital, form of strength.
Rodri’s impact on Manchester City is a testament to the importance of midfielders who operate in the shadows, orchestrating play and providing the foundation upon which the team’s success is built. As the season progresses, the return of Rodri could be the catalyst Manchester City needs to reclaim their dominance and achieve their objectives
